HO-3 vs HO-5 vs HO-6 — Core Differences & Fit for Older Homes in Pittsburgh
Navigate Pittsburgh's historic neighborhoods with confidence. This comprehensive guide breaks down HO-3 vs HO-5 vs HO-6 policies specifically for older homes and condos, including cost drivers, sublimits, and master policy interactions. Learn which policy protects your 1920s Squirrel Hill home or downtown condo best.
Pittsburgh-Specific Older Home FocusHO-3 vs HO-5 vs HO-6 — Core Differences & Fit for Older Homes in Pittsburgh
HO-3 (Home)
Special FormDwelling Perils
Open perils (exclusions listed in policy)Personal Property Perils
Named perils by defaultValuation
Replacement Cost Dwelling ACV Personal Property (RCV via endorsement)Loss Assessment
Not standardBest For
Most single‑family homes needing solid value + flexibilityHO-5 (Home)
Comprehensive FormDwelling Perils
Open perils (broadest standard form)Personal Property Perils
Open perils (broader)Valuation
Replacement Cost Dwelling Personal Property included by default with most carriersLoss Assessment
Not standardBest For
Newer/higher‑value homes; broad personal property protectionHO-6 (Condo)
Unit-Owners FormDwelling Perils
Named perils for unit interior, bettermentsPersonal Property Perils
Named perils for unit interior, bettermentsValuation
Replacement Cost Unit Interior ACV Personal Property (RCV option common)Loss Assessment
Included (sub‑limit) —increase via endorsementBest For
Condo/Co‑op owners coordinating with master policyCommon Exclusions
Flood, earth movement, wear/tear, maintenance issues. Consider separate flood policy and endorsements below.
HO-3 ("Special Form" Homeowners Policy)
What it covers (and doesn't):
- Covers your dwelling (structure) and other structures on an "open perils" basis (i.e. everything except what's explicitly excluded).
- Personal property (your stuff: furniture, electronics, etc.) is covered on a "named perils" basis (only specific perils listed).
- For personal property, reimbursement is typically via Actual Cash Value (ACV) (i.e. value less depreciation) unless you buy an upgrade.
Pros / Cons for older homes:
Pros:
- Lower premium than a more generous plan (less risk for insurer on the personal-property side)
- Good baseline for older homes where replacement cost risks are higher anyway
Cons:
- Because your home is older, maintenance issues, wear and tear, hidden vulnerabilities may lead insurers to exclude or limit some perils or demand high deductibles
- The ACV approach may leave you undercompensated for loss of higher end or upgraded items
When HO-3 makes sense in Pittsburgh's older homes:
- Your replacement cost (structure) is already high; you want to minimize premium burden
- You don't own extremely high value personal property
- You are okay absorbing some depreciation risk on belongings
- Your home condition (roof, plumbing, wiring) is acceptable to insurers (i.e. not severely deteriorated)
HO-5 ("Comprehensive Form" Homeowners Policy)
What it covers:
- Dwelling and other structures: open perils (same as HO-3)
- Personal property: also open perils (i.e. broader coverage)
- Typically pays personal property claims at Replacement Cost Value (RCV) (i.e. to replace rather than depreciated value)
Pros / Cons for older homes:
Pros:
- Stronger coverage for personal property — less "gotcha" in claims
- More peace of mind if you have expensive stuff (electronics, art, high end furniture)
Cons:
- Higher premiums (insurers have more risk)
- Some older homes may fail eligibility or get rated heavily due to risk of latent defects, outdated systems, materials no longer available, etc.
- Some insurers may limit what they'll cover or impose endorsements for special risks in older homes
When HO-5 is preferable:
- You own high value contents that you want full replacement coverage
- You want broader coverage (fewer exclusions) on contents
- You can afford premium uplift
- Your home passes underwriting scrutiny (structure in decent shape, not too many red flags)
HO-6 (Condo / Unit-Owners Policy)
HO-6 is designed for condominium (or cooperative) owners, not standalone single-family homes. In Pittsburgh's older apartment or condo buildings, this is the relevant form.
What HO-6 covers:
- Interior of your unit: walls, floors, built-ins, fixtures, cabinetry, etc. Things the condo master policy doesn't cover
- Personal property: your possessions inside the unit
- Liability: if someone is injured in your unit or you cause damage to others
- Loss of use / additional living expenses: if your unit becomes uninhabitable due to a covered peril, your policy may pay for temporary housing etc.
- Loss assessment coverage: if the condo association's master policy isn't sufficient (or an assessed common area damage), you may be assessed a prorated share — HO-6 may cover that
Particularities in older condo buildings:
- Master policy may only cover structural shell and common areas, possibly leaving more interior risk to you
- The condition of plumbing, wiring, roof, etc in older buildings can raise underwriting scrutiny or exclusions
- Loss assessment clauses are more relevant because shared walls, roofs, pipes, etc may suffer damage beyond your unit, and costs can be passed through
- Because your structural responsibility is limited, the premium is usually lower compared to owning a standalone older house
Typical cost in Pennsylvania / similar areas:
- In Pennsylvania, recent sample data suggests ~$657/year for condo insurance (for typical coverage levels)
- National averages for HO-6 are ~$531/year (varies by state, building, coverage)
🏠 Choose the Right Coverage Type!
Wrong policy type = wasted money. Expert analysis: Get personalized recommendations for HO-3, HO-5, or HO-6 based on your Pittsburgh home.
How to Choose Among HO-3, HO-5, HO-6 (Decision Framework)
Here's a mnemonic/decision tree to help (because I like decision trees; they help me avoid existential dread).
Type of Property
- If it's a condo / unit in a multi-unit building, you likely need HO-6
- If single-family or detached older house, HO-3 or HO-5
Value & Risk of Contents
- If your contents (furniture, appliances, etc.) are modest, HO-3 may suffice
- If you own high-end, custom or expensive items, HO-5 gives stronger protection
Affordability / Premium Sensitivity
- If your budget is tight, HO-3 is typically cheaper
- If you can absorb a moderate premium increase for peace of mind, HO-5 is better
Underwriting / Eligibility
- Older homes sometimes fail eligibility for HO-5 with certain insurers. Check with insurers
- Even in HO-3, insurers might require upgrades (roof, plumbing) before issuing or renewing
Sublimits, Exclusions & Endorsements
- Check for common sublimits (e.g. for jewelry, mold, water backup, ordinance & law)
- For condos, ensure your HO-6 includes enough "loss assessment" coverage
Master (Condo) Policy Review
- In a condo, your HOA/master policy may cover structure and some interior elements; your HO-6 must fill the gaps without redundancy or conflict
Test Real Quotes / Scenario Modeling
- Once you narrow to 1–2 candidate forms, get multiple quotes, plug in high-risk scenarios (fire, water leak, shared structural damage) and stress test the policy
Find the Right Coverage for Your Pittsburgh Home
HO-3, HO-5, or HO-6? Get Expert Guidance
Choosing the right homeowners policy can be confusing! Our Pittsburgh insurance experts understand the unique needs of local homes and can help you select the perfect coverage type while finding the best rates.
Get Coverage Help
Find the right policy type
Cost Drivers for Older Homes (Applicable in Pittsburgh)
Because you asked for "Homeowners Insurance Cost Drivers in Pittsburgh" for HO-3, HO-5, HO-6, here's a prioritized list (with commentary):
Age & Condition of Structure / Systems
Why It Matters: Roof, wiring, plumbing, foundation may be at or nearing end of life → higher risk of claims
Mitigation: Maintain, upgrade, document inspections, replace systems before insurers force you
Replacement Cost / Insured Value
Why It Matters: Older homes may have outdated materials; reconstructing to code is expensive
Mitigation: Use modern cost estimators, include "ordinance & law" coverage
Value & Vulnerability of Contents
Why It Matters: More antique, custom, or high-value personal property increases exposure
Mitigation: Inventory & appraisals, schedule valuables, consider floater riders
Claim History & Loss Ratio
Why It Matters: Insurers penalize past claims (especially water, mold, fire)
Mitigation: Consolidate, avoid small claims, increase deductibles
Location / Neighborhood Risk
Why It Matters: Proximity to fire department, crime rates, flood zone, sewer backup risk
Mitigation: Check municipal fire ratings, choose neighborhoods wisely
Deductibles / Policy Structure
Why It Matters: Higher deductibles reduce premium; endorsement add-ons cost extra
Mitigation: Tailor the policy structure to your risk appetite
Master Policy (for condos)
Why It Matters: The gap between what the master (HOA) covers and what falls to you
Mitigation: Scrutinize master policy carefully, ask for "blow-out" scenarios
Loss Assessment Exposure
Why It Matters: In condos, shared damage (roof, piping, walls) can trigger assessments
Mitigation: Ensure your policy has sufficient loss assessment limits
Exclusions / Sublimits
Why It Matters: Older homes may be excluded from certain risks or be subject to sublimits (e.g. for mold, sinkhole)
Mitigation: Ask for full list of exclusions, negotiate sublimit thresholds
Replacement vs Actual Cash Value
Why It Matters: ACV penalizes you due to depreciation, which is substantial in older properties
Mitigation: Opt for replacement cost coverage when possible
Condo Master Policy Types & Their Interaction with HO-6
Since part of your question is "Condo Master Policy Types and Your HO-6," here's how I'd model that interplay (because I do love modeling interactions).
Master Policy Types (common in the U.S.)
Condo associations (HOAs) typically adopt one of these master (master = association's insurance) policy forms:
Bare Walls-In / Bare Walls-Out
- Bare Walls-In: HOA covers everything except units' interior finishes (inside walls, flooring, cabinetry)
- Bare Walls-Out (or "single entity"): HOA covers walls, flooring, ceilings, sometimes fixtures; owners cover everything inside
Single Entity / All-In
- Covers all interior elements except personal property. Owners insure only contents, liability, upgrades
- All-In / All-Loss: Very generous: Association picks up a lot of what would otherwise be owner liability (less common because costly)
Implications for HO-6 policy drafting:
- If the HOA's policy is Bare Walls-In, your HO-6 must cover interior finishes (flooring, interior walls, built-ins, etc.)
- If HOA policy is Single Entity / All-In, your HO-6 may only need to cover personal property, liability, loss of use, and perhaps improvements
- Discrepancies or gray zones (e.g. pipes within walls, wiring) may lead to disputes — get clarity on what "interior structure" means in your master policy
- Loss assessment coverage is vital to capture your portion of damage to common areas if master policy limits are exhausted
- Be aware of sublimits in your HO-6 (see below) for damage that overlaps with master policy
Common Sublimits (for Pittsburgh / Older Buildings) to Watch Out For
"Common sublimits" means parts of the policy that have lower limits (caps) or restrictions, even if your overall coverage is high. In older homes (or condos) in Pittsburgh, these sublimits can sting you. Here are typical ones and suggestions:
Jewelry, watches, furs, precious metals
Typical Sublimit: Standard policies often limit coverage (e.g. $1,000 or $2,500)
Risk for Older Homes: In older homes, valuables may be vintage, heirlooms, higher value
What to Add: Add a scheduled personal property aka floater / endorsement with appraisals
Water backup / sewer backup
Typical Sublimit: Many policies exclude or cap coverage for backups
Risk for Older Homes: Older plumbing, basements, older sewer lines increase risk
What to Add: Add a "water backup / sewer & sump pump overflow" rider
Ordinance & Law / Building Code Upgrades
Typical Sublimit: Often capped (e.g. 10–20% of dwelling limit)
Risk for Older Homes: Older homes need retrofitting (ADA, fire code, seismic)
What to Add: Increase ordinance & law coverage or buy extended endorsement
Mold, mildew, fungus
Typical Sublimit: Often excluded or subject to sublimits
Risk for Older Homes: Aging water damage is common in older homes
What to Add: Add "fungus / mold removal" endorsement if allowed
Debris removal / cleanup
Typical Sublimit: Policy might cap or apply % limits
Risk for Older Homes: Older homes often have structural collapse, large debris
What to Add: Ensure limit is adequate or increase
Loss of use / additional living expense (ALE)
Typical Sublimit: Some policies cap how much / how long
Risk for Older Homes: In Pittsburgh winters, cost of alternate housing may balloon
What to Add: Increase ALE period or limit
Guest medical payments
Typical Sublimit: Low sublimits (e.g. $1,000–$5,000)
Risk for Older Homes: If someone is injured, costs may exceed that
What to Add: Raise this amount
Loss assessment (in condos)
Typical Sublimit: Many HO-6 policies have limited coverage (e.g. $1,000 or $5,000)
Risk for Older Homes: When shared damage occurs (roof, flooding in common areas) your share may exceed that
What to Add: Negotiate higher loss assessment limit
Electronics / Computers / Fine Arts
Typical Sublimit: Some policies exclude or limit expensive electronics
Risk for Older Homes: Older homes may contain vintage or vulnerable electronics
What to Add: Use scheduled property coverage or special endorsement
Sinkhole / Earth movement / Subsidence
Typical Sublimit: Many policies exclude or severely limit these
Risk for Older Homes: Older foundations, hillsides in Pittsburgh can be susceptible
What to Add: Consider separate coverage if available
Foundation / Underground / Exterior damage (for condos)
Typical Sublimit: HOA's master policy may exclude some exterior parts
Risk for Older Homes: You may be partially responsible in certain policies
What to Add: Clarify master policy scope and add rider if needed
Claims Examples & Coverage Response
Sump overflow after storm
Policy/Endorsement: HO‑3/HO‑6 with water/sewer backup
Notes: Standard policies exclude backup without the endorsement
River flooding into basement
Policy/Endorsement: Separate flood policy (NFIP or private)
Notes: Homeowners/HO‑6 exclude flood from outside water
Kitchen fire triggers code upgrades
Policy/Endorsement: HO‑3/HO‑5 with ordinance or law
Notes: Pays for required code‑driven improvements (limits apply)
Stolen $8,000 ring
Policy/Endorsement: Scheduled personal property rider
Notes: Standard sublimits are low; scheduling removes many limits
Burst pipe damages neighbor's condo
Policy/Endorsement: Personal liability (HO‑3/HO‑5/HO‑6)
Notes: Consider $300k–$500k liability; umbrella for higher limits
Common hallway water damage
Policy/Endorsement: HO‑6 loss assessment endorsement
Notes: Helps with HOA assessments for covered losses/deductibles
Pre‑Bind & Annual Review Checklist
Before You Buy
- Confirm replacement cost valuation method for dwelling and contents
- Review perils for personal property (named vs open)
- Add water/sewer backup if you have a basement
- Check sublimits for jewelry, firearms, collectibles
- For condos, match master policy type and raise loss assessment
Each Renewal
- Update dwelling limit for material/labor cost changes
- Reschedule or appraise high‑value items as needed
- Ask about bundle and mitigation discounts
- Review deductibles and separate wind/hail terms
- Re‑evaluate need for flood or umbrella coverage
Related Pittsburgh Insurance Topics
Deepen your understanding of Pittsburgh home insurance with these comprehensive guides. These resources complement your policy selection process and help you understand factors that impact homeowners insurance cost Pittsburgh residents face, as well as explore smart home discounts Pittsburgh homeowners can leverage.
Flood Insurance Pittsburgh
Complete guide to flood coverage for river-adjacent neighborhoods, including NFIP vs private options.
Read Flood GuideZIP Code Impact on Rates
How Pittsburgh ZIP codes affect home insurance premiums, including flood zones and crime rates.
See ZIP AnalysisCredit-Based Pricing
Understanding how credit scores impact home insurance rates in Pennsylvania.
Learn Credit Impact